Equity vs Commodity Trading – Difference Between Stock Market and Commodity Market

What is Equity?

The equity market or stock market represents the exchange market on which shares of public companies are bought and sold. The simplest definition of equity is that equity refers to the common stock of a company.

Equity is listed on stock exchanges and can be easily traded on the said exchange. Equity shares provide a percentile amount of ownership to the equity holders; equity shares are considered necessary in the overall financial market. These equity shareholders can participate in several managing and other decision-making aspects of the company they hold equity in.
Examples of common equity include common stock, preferred stock, and so on.

What is a Commodity?

The commodity market represents an exchange market where raw material can be bought, sold, or traded. Examples of commodities include grains, precious metals, oil, beef, etc. The commodity is purchased and sold either through the physical delivery of the commodity or through cash settlement.

In general, traders who choose the physical delivery option will have regular daily transaction exposure within a specific commodity’s scope. Cash settlements for commodities are a type of speculation that involves entering into contracts for transactions that will occur at a pre-determined date; when that date arrives, the difference between the original contract price and the current actual price will be settled.

Now that we’ve explored each type of financial instrument’s primary definition, it’s time to compare them to explore other primary differences between the two.

The best way to tackle the critical differences between equity and commodity is to break down their most important characteristics. These characteristics play a crucial factor in the overall risk associated with equity and commodity. In addition, they will influence the number of investments made in each type of instrument, depending on an investor’s financial status, current financial holdings, and overall goals for their financial future.
First, we will look at 14 critical differences between equities and commodities that can be compared head-to-head. Sometimes, these differences can vary on a case-by-case basis; however, they are considered to hold as a general rule of thumb.

Difference between the stock market and commodity market

What is the difference between commodity and equity markets?

The main difference between the equity and commodity markets is that equity holders are partial company owners. The holder of a commodity is not considered an owner of the company (Commodity holders are not entitled to any dividends). Equity shares do not have an expiration date, and the commodity expires at a pre-determined date.

equity vs commodity

Equity vs. Commodity

  • Holder: The holder of equity is considered a shareholder. The holder of a commodity is viewed as an option holder.
  • Ownership: Equity holders are partial owners of the company due to their holding of company stock. The holder of a commodity is not considered an owner of the company.
  • Volatility: The equity market is not notably volatile compared to other financial markets. The commodity market is considered highly volatile compared to other financial markets.
  • Associated Risks: Trading in equity is considered a relatively less risky venture. Trading in the commodity is regarded as a high-risk venture. Beginning investors are recommended to steer clear of high-risk ventures, mainly if they are just now getting a strong financial footing.
  • Dividend: Since equity holders are owners, they are eligible to receive the dividend as a return. Commodity holders are not entitled to any dividends because they are not considered owners of the company.
  •  Exchange-Traded: Equity shares can be traded on various exchanges; the same applies to commodities, though they may be traded on numerous exchanges than equities. The same regulations and rules regarding each exchange will vary on a case-by-case basis.
  • Expiry: Equity shares do not have an expiration date and are considered valid for as long as the equity holder owns their equity shares. On the other hand, Commodity shares expire at a pre-determined date depending on the market and commodity in question.
  • Liquidity: Equity has an overall higher liquidity rate compared to other types of financial instruments. On the other hand, Commodities have a relatively low liquidity rate than equity and other financial instruments.
  •  Time Frame: Equities are long-term contracts that are expected to last for a long time. Some people may hold onto their equity shares for literal decades, depending on the nature of the person’s equity. Employer-given equity tends to be one of the most held-onto types of equity out there today. On the other hand, commodity contracts are short-term and may end in as little as 30 days, depending on a case-by-case basis. The time frame for commodities is, therefore, much shorter than the time frame for equity.
  • Period End Valuation
    The period-end price difference for equity is recorded in the profit and loss account. The period-end price difference for the commodity is recorded as comprehensive income and, when the expiry date approaches, is recorded in the profit and loss account.
  • Regulations: The equity market is free, and there are relatively few associated regulations compared to other types of financial instruments. The commodity market is highly supervised and regulated; it is considered one of the most strict financial instrument markets in operation today.
  • Margin Requirement: There is no margin requirement for equities besides the need for equity to be purchased at market price. The commodity has a high margin market requirement that varies on a case-by-case basis, depending on the commodity, company, and current market trends.
  • Diversification: One equity in the equity market will correlate with other equities’ prices, which means less diversification overall. The price of one commodity in the commodity market has a higher diversification risk since commodities’ prices are not related.
  • Lot Size: There are no lot sizes for equity shares. Commodities are traded in a lot size, which can vary depending on the commodity being traded.

The financial market comprises multiple instruments that investors can use to invest their money and other finances. The end goal of any investment is to earn a profit, which requires essential knowledge of these available financial instruments accessible to investors.

Both equity and commodity are two types of standard financial instruments that investors consider when planning their investment options. Although they are not the only two instruments available on the financial market, they are the most popular and well-known. Equity, in particular, is the most common type of investment made in today’s financial world.
The benefits and disadvantages, features, regulations, and other characteristics of each type of financial instrument all play a role in whether they are considered a good investment for a particular person or a specific financial portfolio. As a result, both equity and commodity can be affected by various factors and must be carefully monitored and tracked to make the best decisions regarding their investments.
Now, let’s take a closer look at each of these two instruments before exploring the key differences between the two that will help investors understand which of these two options is best for their current financial decisions.

Equity and commodity trading from same platform

Equities and commodities you can trade using Metatrader platform. While you can trade all major commodities, only major stocks are available in MT4 platform.

Commodity vs. equity, which is safe?

Commodity assets are high-risk assets and not safe for trading, such as the equity market. The commodity market is highly volatile, and volatility can be considered a risk measurement, but it Is not risk itself. The biggest risk for commodities is political instability, change in regulations, and natural disasters that can impact commodity prices.

Choosing Equity vs. Commodity
When choosing equity versus commodity, investors have many factors to consider before making their final decision. But, first, they will need to consider the above-listed differences between equity and commodity to determine which investment option is best for them.
As a general rule of thumb, equity is much less risky and easier for beginning investors to get into than commodity trading. There are much higher risks associated with commodity trades. Since the market is so volatile, it is challenging to maintain a stable footing, especially if it is new to the market and doesn’t fully understand its investment.

One of the best things that new investors can do is consult with financial planners and advisers to help them make the best decisions for their investments. Most advisors will recommend choosing equity as a starting investor because equities have an overall lower risk and have a higher potential for profit or a higher potential for no significant loss than the riskier commodities.

Commodity markets do have their benefits, however, especially when it comes to risk vs. reward. Although there is a higher risk associated with commodity investments, the potential for a greater reward is well. As a result, investors with more experience may want to consider choosing commodity investments as part of their overall investment portfolio, especially if they’re going to diversify their investments across various financial instruments.
It is possible to have both commodity and equity investments, of course; this is typically recommended only for experienced investors who understand the market and are willing to play with riskier stakes than trading in equity alone.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the critical differences between equity and commodity is essential for anyone with a serious interest in investing and the financial market. While some of the differences are small, many play a vital role in the overall risk, reward, and profitability of these two different investment types.
Investors should carefully consider the above differences when making that serious financial decision regarding what financial instruments they want to play on the market. Hopefully, the above guide has helped you understand the basics of commodity vs. equity to help you get started on the journey towards making more informed investment and other financial decisions.



Igor has been a trader since 2007. Currently, Igor works for several prop trading companies. He is an expert in financial niche, long-term trading, and weekly technical levels. The primary field of Igor's research is the application of machine learning in algorithmic trading. Education: Computer Engineering and Ph.D. in machine learning. Igor regularly publishes trading-related videos on the Fxigor Youtube channel. To contact Igor write on: igor@forex.in.rs

Trade gold and silver. Visit the broker's page and start trading high liquidity spot metals - the most traded instruments in the world.

Trade Gold & Silver


Recent Posts