Table of Contents
In this interview, trader James Bentley—who started in 2009 at ICAP and now operates out of Dubai—breaks down a no-nonsense trading style built on trend, zones, and momentum. He explains why he largely ignores fundamentals in today’s tug-of-war macro environment, how he narrows a 150-market universe to 8–9 seasonal opportunities each month, and why beginners should embrace simple execution on the 1-hour chart. If you’re new to the game or stuck chasing “perfect” setups, Bentley’s philosophy of keeping it simple—and focusing on currency strength/weakness, structure, and a 20-period moving average—will feel like a breath of fresh air.
You’ll learn the core of Bentley’s strategy: use a 20-year seasonal “true path” to build a monthly watchlist, align with market structure, then trigger off momentum—often with an 8–10 bar push from the 20MA—targeting clean 1:1s while risking 1–2%. He also hits the mindset traps that kill consistency (greed, forcing trades, gold addiction), why most retail traders misuse prop accounts, and how journaling/backtesting builds the confidence to execute the same edge again and again. If you want a practical trader strategy you can apply this week—not next year—this piece distills Bentley’s playbook into crisp, beginner-friendly rules you can actually follow.
James Bentley Playbook & Strategy: How He Actually Trades
Market Selection: Seasonality First, Everything Else Second
Bentley starts wide and narrows fast. Each month, he screens ~150 markets, then keeps only the 8–9 that are currently tracking their historical “true path,” using a 20-year weighted seasonal average to decide what’s in play and what’s noise. He largely sidesteps fundamentals in today’s tug-of-war macro backdrop and lets seasonality plus current behavior do the heavy lifting.
- Build a monthly watchlist by comparing live price to a 20-year weighted seasonal path; keep only instruments currently “in line.”
- Give entries a ±3-day buffer around typical seasonal turning dates rather than pinpointing a day.
- Aim for 8–9 “on-track” markets for the month; ditch the rest to avoid spreading attention thin.
- Treat fundamentals as background noise; trade the behavior that’s actually printing today.
Instruments & Timeframe: Keep It Tight, Keep It Liquid
He prefers a small core list (often majors like EURUSD and GBPUSD) and does his execution work on the 1-hour chart. Less is more: mastery and focus beat scanning dozens of random tickers every morning.
- Pick 1–3 core FX majors to specialize in (e.g., EURUSD, GBPUSD) and add only the seasonal outliers from your monthly list.
- Run your playbook primarily on the H1 for clean structure and session-friendly momentum windows.
- If a core pair ranges with no momentum, rotate to another seasonally “on-track” product rather than forcing trades.
Trend ID: Two Cycles Confirm, Then Play Continuations
You’re not catching tops or bottoms—you’re confirming trend and riding the next leg. Two swings are usually enough confirmation; after that, continuation price action tells you when momentum is ready to resume.
- Require two clear cycles (higher highs/higher lows or lower highs/lower lows) before treating a move as a tradable trend.
- Classify the setup as beginning/middle/end of trend to set expectations for hold time and target ambition.
- Use continuation candles (bullish/bearish engulfing, inside-bar breaks) as go-signals in the direction of the trend.
Entry Trigger: The 20MA “Buffer” and the First Bounce
Bentley’s execution is built around a simple buffer: the 20-period moving average on H1. Let price cycle back to the 20MA, then look for a clean rejection to re-join the trend—no perfectionism, just momentum aligned with currency strength/weakness.
- Only trade in the direction of verified currency strength/weakness and the established trend.
- Treat the 20MA as your re-entry zone; don’t wait for the “perfect” pullback that rarely comes.
- Valid bounce examples: inside-bar close back above/below 20MA in trend, engulfing candle, or pin-bar rejection.
- Focus on the early stage of a fresh 20MA bounce; that’s where the 8–10 bar push often lives on majors.
Stops, Targets, and Trade Management: 1:1 Done Right
He keeps risk tight and results repeatable. Stops live behind the 20MA, and the base expectation is a clean 1:1—capturing the day’s momentum without turning a day trade into a multi-week hold.
- Place the stop just beyond the 20MA on the other side of the rejection candle.
- On H1 majors, plan for ~20–25 points of risk, targeting ~20–25 points reward for a baseline 1:1.
- Skip partials; either the thesis plays out or it doesn’t—simplicity helps execution discipline.
- Accept that some 1:1s could run much farther; the edge is banking the high-probability chunk consistently.
Session & Frequency: Trade the Juice, Not the Clock
He describes himself as a day/session trader looking for liquidity, volatility, and trend—often focusing on the European morning and taking one to two quality trades when the tape is hot. Some days, he takes nothing.
- Plan your A-setups around sessions that reliably deliver momentum (e.g., London open + first few hours).
- Cap yourself at 1–2 trades per day to protect selectivity; zero is a valid outcome when conditions aren’t there.
- If your core pair goes dead, rotate to another item from the monthly seasonal shortlist rather than forcing the chart.
Mindset: Retail Game, Retail Rules
Bentley’s take is refreshingly unromantic: you’re not an institution, and you don’t need to be. Forget the bank-desk fantasy and play a retail-friendly probability game with simple, testable rules.
- Stop comparing yourself to banks/hedge funds; different constraints, different tools—your edge is simplicity.
- Define your win-rate/expectancy goals and execute the same criteria every time; let big players move price, you harvest the clean chunk.
- Journal seasonal picks, 20MA bounces, and 1:1 outcomes to validate the edge and spot drift.
Putting It Together: A One-Look Playbook You Can Run This Week
The flow is linear: seasonal shortlist → confirm trend with two cycles → 20MA bounce trigger → stop behind 20MA → 1:1 base target. Keep the universe small, the rules tight, and the expectations realistic—and momentum does the work.
- Weekly: build the 8–9 instrument watchlist aligned with the seasonal “true path.”
- Daily: mark trend state on H1 and highlight the 20MA zone for each watchlist item.
- During your session: take only clean 20MA rejections in trend; stop beyond 20MA; aim for the session’s 1:1.
- Post-trade: log result and whether the move produced the expected 8–10 bar push; adjust expectations, not rules.
Size Risk First: Fixed Percent Per Trade and Daily Loss Cap
James Bentley starts every plan with risk, not entries. He decides the percent of equity he’ll risk per trade first—typically a small, repeatable slice—and then sizes the position from the stop distance back to that fixed percent. That keeps every bet uniform, even when volatility shifts or the setup looks “too good to miss.” Once the trade is on, he respects the math and refuses to widen stops or “average down” to save a loser.
Bentley also sets a hard daily loss cap to protect the mental game and the account. If that cap is hit, he logs off, no debate, because decision quality falls fast after emotional hits. He treats the cap like a seatbelt: it feels restrictive until it saves your month. With fixed-percent risk and a strict daily cutoff, he turns randomness into a controlled business and lets winners—not impulse—drive the P&L.
Trade Momentum, Not Predictions: Use Structure and 20MA Rejections on H1
James Bentley doesn’t guess tops or bottoms—he waits for structure to prove direction. On the H1 chart, he marks higher highs and higher lows (or the inverse) and only then hunts entries. The trigger is simple: let price pull back toward the 20-period moving average, then take the clean rejection back into trend. No crystal ball, just momentum re-joining after a controlled pause.
Bentley wants confirmation in the candle that tags the 20MA and rejects—engulfing, inside-bar break, or a decisive close back with trend. Stops go just beyond the rejection candle on the other side of the 20MA, keeping risk tight. If the structure breaks, he’s out; predictions don’t override tape. This way, James Bentley trades what’s happening—not what he hopes will happen.
Let Volatility Guide Allocation: Rotate to Markets With Session Energy
James Bentley treats volatility like the fuel gauge for opportunity. If a pair’s session range dries up, he doesn’t force trades—he rotates to something with juice. He’ll look at recent ATR or session range to decide where to deploy size, scaling risk down when ranges compress and up (within limits) when they expand. London hours often lead his playbook, but he’ll switch instruments rather than chase noise on a sleepy chart.
Bentley uses simple rules to keep it practical: no entry unless the current session range clears a minimum threshold; no second attempt if the first A-setup fizzles in a dead tape. He caps simultaneous exposure so one bursty product doesn’t multiply risk across correlated pairs. When volatility spikes around events, he trims size but stays open to clean momentum re-joins. By letting volatility dictate allocation, James Bentley keeps attention—and capital—where the market is actually moving.
Diversify Smartly: Mix Majors, Seasonality Plays, and Timeframe Durations
James Bentley builds diversification the way a craftsman builds a toolkit—each piece has a job. He keeps a core of liquid majors for dependable execution, then layers in a few seasonal opportunities that are currently tracking their historical “true path.” Instead of piling on correlated pairs, he spreads exposure across different underlyings and makes sure not all entries live on the same timeframe. That way, if an H1 idea stalls, a higher-timeframe swing or a separate seasonal play can still carry the week.
Bentley also diversifies by strategy mechanics, not just tickers. A momentum re-join on EURUSD is a different bet from a seasonal glide on an index future, even if both are long risk. He limits the number of concurrent trades to prevent hidden correlation shocks and avoids duplicating the same thesis across look-alike charts. With this approach, James Bentley turns a handful of simple edges into a portfolio that’s sturdier, calmer, and less dependent on any single market behaving perfectly.
Process Over Outcome: Journal Setups, Repeat Rules, Stop Forcing Trades
James Bentley builds consistency by obsessing over the process, not the P&L. He journals each setup in plain language—trend state, 20MA context, trigger candle, stop/target, and session conditions—so he can spot exactly where execution drifts. If a trade doesn’t meet the rules, it’s not “almost there”; it’s a pass. He reviews the journal weekly to highlight patterns he wants to repeat and habits he needs to kill.
When emotions flare, James Bentley leans on prewritten rules: no revenge trades, no doubling size after a loss, and no new positions once the daily loss cap is hit. He treats boredom as a setup killer and closes the platform when he catches himself hunting for a trade. Winners are graded on rule adherence first, profit second, because a bad win is just a delayed loss. Over time, this process-first mindset turns a choppy equity curve into a steadier climb—and keeps him playing a game he can actually win.
In the end, James Bentley’s edge is radical simplicity executed with discipline. He filters a wide universe down to a handful of seasonality-aligned markets, then lets structure and momentum do the talking on the H1 chart. Entries are mechanical: wait for trend confirmation, let price pull back to the 20MA, take the first clean rejection, and tuck the stop just beyond the moving average. Targets are pragmatic—often a straight 1:1 that captures the session’s chunk without turning a day trade into a campaign.
He treats himself like a session trader: hunt volatility, liquidity, and trend during the hours that actually move, and rotate to instruments with “juice” instead of forcing sleepy charts. Fundamentals are background noise in a tug-of-war macro world; behavior on the tape wins. The mindset matches the mechanics: you’re a retail trader playing a probability game, not an institution chasing secrets—log your rules, size by fixed risk, respect the daily loss cap, and let repetition harden your edge.
What stands out about James Bentley is how transferable this is: a monthly seasonal shortlist, two cycles to confirm trend, 20MA as a buffer, rejection candle as trigger, stop behind the 20, and get paid on the clean move. Surround yourself with traders who reinforce those standards, because the environment compounds behavior just like edge compounds returns. Keep it simple, keep it structured, and let the market do the heavy lifting.
