Table of Contents
In this interview, 22-year-old trader Umar Punjabi sits down on Titans of Tomorrow to unpack how he went from navigating India’s tough trading restrictions to building a full-time life and career in Dubai. He’s candid about the noise in the Indian education scene, why most people skip the boring work, and how he simplified his edge around supply/demand zones and real market confirmation instead of ego-driven lines. You’ll also hear why he weights psychology at 90%, how prop firms became a realistic on-ramp for Indian traders, and the mindset shift that helped him stop forcing trades and start respecting sessions, timing, and risk.
Read on to learn the exact trader strategy Punjabi uses: how he defines a valid zone, the “prove it” confirmation he waits for, and the backtesting rules that keep his data honest (session, timeframe, and realistic trade counts). He breaks down standardized risk, when he halves size after two losses in a week, and why focusing on small, repeatable returns scales better with prop funding than chasing hero trades. If you’re new, this is a clean, beginner-friendly blueprint; if you’re experienced, it’s a timely reminder to restrict, simplify, and let the market prove your idea before you act.
Umar Punjabi Playbook & Strategy: How He Actually Trades
The Edge: Simple Supply–Demand With “Prove-It” Confirmation
Umar keeps the core of his trader strategy intentionally simple: identify where price made a strong move before, and make the market “prove” that level still matters before committing risk. It’s a day-trader’s edge built around clean zones, patience, and repeatability.
- Mark zones where price previously launched or rejected in a “strong move” (clear displacement, clean candles, little overlap). Only trade when price returns to those zones.
- Treat zones like hypotheses: you don’t buy/sell because you drew a box—you trade after the market reacts and confirms the level still has order-flow memory.
- Default to day-trading horizons; plan to be in a position for a couple of hours, not days. Build rules for entries/exits that fit this holding period.
Building the System: General Knowledge → Specialize → Codify
He’s big on earning the basics first, then specializing in what clicks (for him, supply/demand and S/R), and finally codifying rules into a named playbook. This sequence keeps you from copy-pasting indicators you don’t understand.
- Phase 1: Study widely (market structure, sessions, orders, risk, psychology) before buying anything. Know essentials like “always use a stop-loss.”
- Phase 2: Choose a lane that logically fits you (e.g., supply/demand if structure is intuitive) and build your rules around that concept.
- Phase 3: Write a one-paragraph strategy definition you could explain to a stranger. If you can’t summarize it, you can’t trade it.
Setup Selection: What Qualifies as a Zone Worth Trading
Not every level deserves your money. Umar filters hard for quality so that fewer, better trades do the heavy lifting.
- Prior move must show decisive displacement (wide candles, minimal wicks in the impulse). Skip choppy origins.
- Freshness filter: prefer zones price hasn’t revisited multiple times; each touch depletes order-flow.
- Location matters: zones near session opens (London/NY) can carry more energy—plan around when liquidity appears. (Umar trades intraday; time-boxing is key.)
Confirmation: “Let Price Prove It”
He doesn’t “knife-catch” blindly. He waits for evidence that participants still defend the zone.
- At the zone: require a reaction + a minor structure shift (e.g., a micro HH/HL for longs or LH/LL for shorts) before entering.
- If the first reaction is weak or instantly retraced, stand down; the market just said “not today.”
- If no confirmation within your pre-set time window, cancel the idea—opportunity cost is real for a day trader.
Entries & Exits: Rules You Can Apply Today
A good plan survives nerves. Umar’s intraday structure translates into crisp execution rules.
- Entry trigger: only after your confirmation rule fires; no anticipatory market orders at untouched zones.
- Stop-loss: beyond the zone’s other side (not inside the noise). Stops are non-negotiable.
- First target: the nearest opposing structure (prior pivot/imbalance fill). Trail or scale only if the market continues to “prove it.”
- Hard maximum hold: 2–3 hours unless already partialed and trailing efficiently.
Risk: Standardized, Boring, and Sustainable
Umar’s mantra is clear—risk only what you can afford to lose—and systematize it so one trade can’t wreck your week.
- Fixed R: choose a % per trade that you can execute without flinching (e.g., 0.5R–1R of account per setup).
- Weekly circuit-breaker: after two consecutive losses, halve risk for the rest of the week or stop for 24 hours.
- No adding to losers, ever. If new information invalidates the thesis, flatten.
Timing & Sessions: Restrict to When You Have Edge
Edge is time-dependent. Umar day-trades; that demands discipline about when you’re allowed to click.
- Pre-define your session windows (e.g., London or New York) and only trade inside them. Outside hours = no entries.
- If confirmation hasn’t happened by the end of your window, cancel the trade idea, log it, and move on.
- One clean A-setup beats three B-setups at random times. Your best hours deserve your best focus.
Psychology: Discipline Comes After You Have an Edge
Umar’s view: psychology isn’t a magic fix; it matters most once a real edge exists. That framing saves years of spinning wheels.
- Don’t journal “feelings” in a vacuum—journal rules and whether you followed them.
- Build pre-trade checklists that force you to articulate why the level should work today.
- Post-trade, score only process (zone quality, confirmation, risk, timing), not P/L.
Backtesting & Journaling: Prove It Before You Scale
Before you chase funding or size, Umar stresses proving the edge in data and notes. That’s how uncertainty turns into conviction.
- Backtest the exact rules you’ll trade live: zones, confirmation trigger, session window, hold time, and exit logic.
- Cap trades per session in the test to match reality (e.g., max 1–2).
- Journal screenshots at entry/exit with a 10-word reason (“M15 demand retest + BOS; NY open; TP at prior H1 swing”).
Prop Funding & Scaling: Earn It With Repeatability
His path makes prop challenges viable after you can demonstrate repeatable behavior, not before. That order keeps the cart behind the horse.
- Minimum bar: 2–3 months of live or sim data following your written rules with positive expectancy.
- Size through rules, not emotion: keep fixed R, and expand size only after hitting a pre-defined equity or win-rate milestone.
- Multiple small funded accounts can diversify operational risk better than one oversized account (same rules cloned).
Education & Due Diligence: Avoid the Noise, Keep the Edge
Umar is outspoken about avoiding hype and buying time with self-education first. That mindset protects your account and your focus.
- Get the basics for free first; only then consider structured learning if it shortens your curve.
- Vet any mentor by their process (risk, sessions, logs), not cars or follower counts.
- Non-negotiables: stop-loss usage, risk caps, and proof of rules applied consistently. If those aren’t visible, walk.
Size Risk First: Fixed-R, Volatility-Adjusted Position Sizing
Umar Punjabi starts with risk, not charts. He decides the maximum he’s willing to lose before he thinks about entries, using a fixed-R amount that doesn’t change just because a setup “feels” better. That fixed-R then gets translated into position size based on the stop distance, so a wider stop means fewer contracts and a tighter stop means more—never the other way around. By locking the dollar risk first, Umar ensures one loss can’t derail the week, and every trade is just another execution of the same risk template.
From there, Umar Punjabi layers in volatility awareness. He shrinks size when ranges expand and spreads widen, because the same stop distance now carries more intraday noise. He avoids cramming a big position into a choppy window; instead, he scales only when conditions are clean and the stop is defensible. The goal is simple: keep R constant, let volatility dictate size, and make every trade survivable so you can show up again tomorrow.
Trade the Mechanic, Not the Forecast: Rules Over Gut
Umar Punjabi doesn’t try to outguess the market; he runs a checklist. He treats each setup like a machine with on/off switches—zone quality, session timing, confirmation pattern—either the lights turn green or he passes. If one light is red, he skips the trade, even if the chart looks “tempting.” That removes the need to be right and replaces it with the need to be consistent.
When a valid signal prints, Umar Punjabi executes without embellishment: enter, stop where the thesis is wrong, first target at the nearest opposing structure. No adding size mid-trade because a candle “feels strong,” no moving stops to avoid the loss, and no revenge entries after a miss. The point is to win by repetition, not prediction—let the rules do the heavy lifting while emotions sit on the bench.
Diversify Smart: Underlying, Strategy, and Holding Duration Buckets
Umar Punjabi spreads his risk across buckets so one bad theme can’t nuke the day. He separates underlyings by behavior—if he’s long a momentum index like NAS100, he won’t also pile into similarly risk-on FX pairs; that’s just the same bet in disguise. He also avoids holding multiple trades that all rely on the same driver (e.g., dollar weakness), keeping only the clearest expression of the idea. The rule is simple: if the trades would likely win or lose together, pick one and cut the rest.
He also diversifies by strategy and duration. If one setup is a mean-reversion tag of demand, the next should ideally be a continuation play or a breakout retest—not another copy-paste of the first. And he staggers holding times: a quick scalp, an intraday swing, and maybe one “runner” only if it’s funded by partials. Umar Punjabi caps concurrent risk (e.g., no more than two positions live, total risk <2R) and rotates out when correlations spike. This way the book isn’t just diversified on paper; it’s diversified where it counts—by driver, by tactic, and by time in market.
Prefer Defined Risk Setups; Ban Averaging Down and Martingale
Umar Punjabi treats undefined risk like a leak in the hull—ignore it and the boat sinks. He chooses setups where the invalidation is obvious on the chart, so the stop-loss sits beyond a clear line in the sand, not somewhere “approximate.” If the level breaks with intent, the thesis is wrong and he’s out—no exceptions. Defined risk keeps every trade finite, every loss payable, and the account alive long enough for edge to compound.
Equally, Umar Punjabi hard-bans averaging down and any flavor of martingale. If price moves against him, he doesn’t “improve” the average; he exits, logs why, and waits for a fresh, confirmed setup. Adding size to losers only deepens a bad idea and blurs the original risk math. His mantra is clean: one entry, one stop, planned size, and a graceful exit when the story changes.
Execution Discipline: Session Windows, One A-Setup, Flawless Journaling
Umar Punjabi keeps his trading inside strict session windows so he’s never forcing entries in dead liquidity. He predefines London and New York execution hours, then shuts the platform outside those blocks to protect focus and stats. Within the window he hunts for exactly one A-setup—not three, not “almost”—and passes on the day if the market doesn’t show it. This removes FOMO, preserves energy, and keeps his win rate tied to quality, not activity.
After each trade, Umar Punjabi journals like a pro: screenshot, reason for entry in one short sentence, rule checklist, and post-mortem on process adherence. He scores the trade on rule-following, not P/L, so a disciplined loss rates higher than a sloppy win. Patterns from the journal feed small rule upgrades—tightening session filters, refining confirmation, or adjusting first targets. The result is a tight feedback loop where discipline creates clarity, clarity creates confidence, and confidence makes the next A-setup easier to execute.
In the end, Umar Punjabi’s message is brutally simple: protect the downside, systematize the upside, and let the market do the talking. He builds every decision around a fixed-R risk template, hunts only the cleanest supply–demand zones, and waits for price to “prove it” before committing. Sessions are sacred, confirmation is non-negotiable, and undefined risk is a hard pass. If the thesis breaks, he’s out—no averaging down, no heroics, no stories.
What makes this work is the feedback loop. Umar journals process, not emotions; he backtests the exact rules he’ll trade; and he scales only when the data says the edge is real. Diversification happens across driver, tactic, and holding time—not just tickers—so one bad theme can’t wipe the day. It’s a professional blueprint wrapped in retail-friendly rules: size by volatility, trade mechanics over forecasts, restrict your hours, and execute one A-setup with flawless discipline. If you copy nothing else, copy the risk rules and the habit of making the market prove your idea.
